Under betterFors don't drop the trailing map if it would result in a different type (also drop _ => ())

compiler/src/dotty/tools/dotc/Compiler.scala

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ import parsing.Parser
 import Phases.Phase
 import transform.*
 import backend.jvm.{CollectSuperCalls, GenBCode}
-import localopt.StringInterpolatorOpt
+import localopt.{StringInterpolatorOpt, DropForMap}
 
 /** The central class of the dotc compiler. The job of a compiler is to create
  *  runs, which process given `phases` in a given `rootContext`.
@@ -68,7 +68,8 @@ class Compiler {
          new InlineVals,             // Check right hand-sides of an `inline val`s
          new ExpandSAMs,             // Expand single abstract method closures to anonymous classes
          new ElimRepeated,           // Rewrite vararg parameters and arguments
-         new RefChecks) ::           // Various checks mostly related to abstract members and overriding
+         new RefChecks,              // Various checks mostly related to abstract members and overriding
+         new DropForMap) ::          // Drop unused trailing map calls in for comprehensions
     List(new semanticdb.ExtractSemanticDB.AppendDiagnostics) :: // Attach warnings to extracted SemanticDB and write to .semanticdb file
     List(new init.Checker) ::        // Check initialization of objects
     List(new ProtectedAccessors,     // Add accessors for protected members

compiler/src/dotty/tools/dotc/ast/Desugar.scala

@@ -64,6 +64,11 @@ object desugar {
    */
   val PolyFunctionApply: Property.Key[Unit] = Property.StickyKey()
 
+  /** An attachment key to indicate that an Apply is created as a last `map`
+   *  scall in a for-comprehension.
+   */
+  val TrailingForMap: Property.Key[Unit] = Property.StickyKey()
+
   /** What static check should be applied to a Match? */
   enum MatchCheck {
     case None, Exhaustive, IrrefutablePatDef, IrrefutableGenFrom
@@ -1966,14 +1971,8 @@ object desugar {
      *
      *  3.
      *
-     *    for (P <- G) yield P  ==>  G
-     *
-     *  If betterFors is enabled, P is a variable or a tuple of variables and G is not a withFilter.
-     *
      *    for (P <- G) yield E  ==>  G.map (P => E)
      *
-     *    Otherwise
-     *
      *  4.
      *
      *    for (P_1 <- G_1; P_2 <- G_2; ...) ...
@@ -2149,11 +2148,13 @@ object desugar {
       enums match {
         case Nil if betterForsEnabled => body
         case (gen: GenFrom) :: Nil =>
+          val aply = Apply(rhsSelect(gen, mapName), makeLambda(gen, body))
           if betterForsEnabled
-            && gen.checkMode != GenCheckMode.Filtered // results of withFilter have the wrong type
-            && deepEquals(gen.pat, body)
-          then gen.expr  // avoid a redundant map with identity
-          else Apply(rhsSelect(gen, mapName), makeLambda(gen, body))
+          && gen.checkMode != GenCheckMode.Filtered // results of withFilter have the wrong type
+          && (deepEquals(gen.pat, body) || deepEquals(body, Tuple(Nil)))
+          then
+            aply.putAttachment(TrailingForMap, ())
+          aply
         case (gen: GenFrom) :: (rest @ (GenFrom(_, _, _) :: _)) =>
           val cont = makeFor(mapName, flatMapName, rest, body)
           Apply(rhsSelect(gen, flatMapName), makeLambda(gen, cont))
@@ -2164,7 +2165,10 @@ object desugar {
           val selectName =
             if rest.exists(_.isInstanceOf[GenFrom]) then flatMapName
             else mapName
-          Apply(rhsSelect(gen, selectName), makeLambda(gen, cont))
+          val aply = Apply(rhsSelect(gen, selectName), makeLambda(gen, cont))
+          if selectName == mapName && (deepEquals(gen.pat, body) || deepEquals(body, Tuple(Nil))) then
+            aply.pushAttachment(TrailingForMap, ())
+          aply
         case (gen: GenFrom) :: (rest @ GenAlias(_, _) :: _) =>
           val (valeqs, rest1) = rest.span(_.isInstanceOf[GenAlias])
           val pats = valeqs map { case GenAlias(pat, _) => pat }

compiler/src/dotty/tools/dotc/transform/localopt/DropForMap.scala

@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
+package dotty.tools.dotc
+package transform.localopt
+
+import dotty.tools.dotc.ast.tpd.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.core.Decorators.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.core.Contexts.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.core.StdNames.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.core.Symbols.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.core.Types.*
+import dotty.tools.dotc.transform.MegaPhase.MiniPhase
+import dotty.tools.dotc.ast.desugar
+
+/** Drop unused trailing map calls in for comprehensions.
+  * We can drop the map call if:
+  * - it won't change the type of the expression, and
+  * - the function is an identity function or a const function to unit.
+  *
+  * The latter condition is checked in [[Desugar.scala#makeFor]]
+  */
+class DropForMap extends MiniPhase:
+  import DropForMap.*
+
+  override def phaseName: String = DropForMap.name
+
+  override def description: String = DropForMap.description
+
+  override def transformApply(tree: Apply)(using Context): Tree =
+    if !tree.hasAttachment(desugar.TrailingForMap) then tree
+    else tree match
+      case aply @ Apply(MapCall(f), List(Lambda(List(param), body)))
+      if f.tpe =:= aply.tpe => // make sure that the type of the expression won't change
+        f // drop the map call
+      case _ =>
+        tree.removeAttachment(desugar.TrailingForMap)
+        tree
+
+  private object Lambda:
+    def unapply(tree: Tree)(using Context): Option[(List[ValDef], Tree)] =
+      tree match
+        case Block(List(defdef: DefDef), Closure(Nil, ref, _))
+        if ref.symbol == defdef.symbol && !defdef.paramss.exists(_.forall(_.isType)) =>
+          Some((defdef.termParamss.flatten, defdef.rhs))
+        case _ => None
+
+  private object MapCall:
+    def unapply(tree: Tree)(using Context): Option[Tree] = tree match
+      case Select(f, nme.map) => Some(f)
+      case Apply(fn, _) => unapply(fn)
+      case TypeApply(fn, _) => unapply(fn)
+      case _ => None
+
+object DropForMap:
+  val name: String = "dropForMap"
+  val description: String = "Drop unused trailing map calls in for comprehensions"

docs/_docs/reference/experimental/better-fors.md

@@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ Additionally this extension changes the way `for`-comprehensions are desugared.
     This change makes the desugaring more intuitive and avoids unnecessary `map` calls, when an alias is not followed by a guard.
 
 2. **Avoiding Redundant `map` Calls**:
-    When the result of the `for`-comprehension is the same expression as the last generator pattern, the desugaring avoids an unnecessary `map` call. but th eequality of the last pattern and the result has to be able to be checked syntactically, so it is either a variable or a tuple of variables.
+    When the result of the `for`-comprehension is the same expression as the last generator pattern, the desugaring avoids an unnecessary `map` call. But the equality of the last pattern and the result has to be able to be checked syntactically, so it is either a variable or a tuple of variables. There is also a special case for dropping the `map`, if its body is a constant function, that returns `()` (`Unit` constant).
     **Current Desugaring**:
       ```scala
       for {

tests/pos/better-fors-i21804.scala

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+import scala.language.experimental.betterFors
+
+case class Container[A](val value: A) {
+  def map[B](f: A => B): Container[B] = Container(f(value))
+}
+
+sealed trait Animal
+case class Dog() extends Animal
+
+def opOnDog(dog: Container[Dog]): Container[Animal] =
+  for
+    v <- dog
+  yield v

tests/run/better-fors-map-elim.check

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+MySome(())
+MySome(2)
+MySome((2,3))
+MySome((2,(3,4)))

tests/run/better-fors-map-elim.scala

@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
+import scala.language.experimental.betterFors
+
+class myOptionModule(doOnMap: => Unit) {
+  sealed trait MyOption[+A] {
+    def map[B](f: A => B): MyOption[B] = this match {
+      case MySome(x) => {
+        doOnMap
+        MySome(f(x))
+      }
+      case MyNone => MyNone
+    }
+    def flatMap[B](f: A => MyOption[B]): MyOption[B] = this match {
+      case MySome(x) => f(x)
+      case MyNone => MyNone
+    }
+  }
+  case class MySome[A](x: A) extends MyOption[A]
+  case object MyNone extends MyOption[Nothing]
+  object MyOption {
+    def apply[A](x: A): MyOption[A] = MySome(x)
+  }
+}
+
+object Test extends App {
+
+  val myOption = new myOptionModule(println("map called"))
+
+  import myOption.*
+
+  def portablePrintMyOption(opt: MyOption[Any]): Unit =
+    if opt == MySome(()) then
+      println("MySome(())")
+    else
+      println(opt)
+
+  val z = for {
+    a <- MyOption(1)
+    b <- MyOption(())
+  } yield ()
+
+  portablePrintMyOption(z)
+
+  val z2 = for {
+    a <- MyOption(1)
+    b <- MyOption(2)
+  } yield b
+
+  portablePrintMyOption(z2)
+
+  val z3 = for {
+    a <- MyOption(1)
+    (b, c) <- MyOption((2, 3))
+  } yield (b, c)
+
+  portablePrintMyOption(z3)
+
+  val z4 = for {
+    a <- MyOption(1)
+    (b, (c, d)) <- MyOption((2, (3, 4)))
+  } yield (b, (c, d))
+
+  portablePrintMyOption(z4)
+
+}